1:1 vs Group Tutoring: Which Format Delivers the Best Results?

As private tutoring continues to grow in popularity across the UK, many families are asking the same question: is one-on-one tutoring better than group tuition? Both formats offer unique advantages and potential drawbacks depending on your child’s learning style, goals, and budget.

In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between 1:1 and group tutoring, explore how online tutoring services are reshaping both options, and help you decide which format is the best fit for your needs.

Understanding the Role of Tutoring in Today’s Learning Landscape

Group tutoring typically involves teaching a small number of students together, either online or in person. It can be a helpful option for learners who benefit from peer interaction, shared discussions, and a more social learning environment.

These sessions often include aspects of collaborative learning, where students support each other’s progress through group activities and open conversations. This can help develop soft skills like communication and teamwork, especially in younger learners.

That said, group formats may not offer the same level of flexibility, personalisation, or focused academic support as one-on-one tutoring. For students preparing for exams, catching up after falling behind, or aiming for specific goals, 1:1 sessions often provide more structure and individual attention.

As online tutoring services continue to grow, families now have more options than ever, making it easier to choose a format that truly fits their child’s needs.

One-on-One Tutoring: Pros & Cons

💙Pros:

• One-to-one tutoring offers personalised support, meaning every session is shaped around the student’s level, pace, and specific challenges. Whether they’re catching up or pushing ahead, the learning is entirely tailored.
• With no other students in the room, the student benefits from focused attention, allowing for deeper discussions, fewer distractions, and faster clarification of difficult topics.
• Flexible scheduling is another big plus, sessions can be arranged around family plans, school hours, or other activities without needing to coordinate with a group.
• Many students experience faster progress in a one-on-one setting, as they’re able to move through material at their own pace without being held back or rushed by others.
• Tutors can also provide customised exam prep, focusing on exactly what the student needs, whether that’s past paper practice, tricky exam techniques, or revising key topics before a big test.
• Importantly, this setting helps with confidence building. Without the pressure of speaking in front of peers, students are more likely to ask questions and engage with the material.
• And as they begin to see consistent improvement, there’s a strong sense of motivation through progress, each small win pushes them to keep going.

🔴Cons:

• Because the tutor is dedicating their full-time and attention to one student, providing personalised sessions, private tuition may have a higher cost.
• There’s also limited social interaction, which means students might miss out on the benefits of working with peers, like idea-sharing, discussion, or motivation from classmates.

Group Tuition: Pros & Cons

💙Pros:

• Group tutoring is cost-effective, as families can split the cost of each session, making it a more affordable long-term option than private lessons.
• It encourages collaborative learning, where students engage in discussions, ask questions, and learn from one another in a shared environment.
• There’s often strong peer motivation, seeing others make progress can inspire students to stay focused, keep up, and push themselves further.
• These sessions promote skill development, helping students build teamwork, communication, and time management through group projects and interactive activities.
• Working together can also boost grades, as different perspectives and tutor feedback help clarify concepts and strengthen understanding.
• Confidence through peer learning is another key benefit. Group discussions and shared tasks help quieter students feel more comfortable speaking up and participating.
• Being surrounded by others also creates motivation from peers, a sense of friendly competition and encouragement that keeps students engaged.

🔴Cons:

• The biggest limitation is less individual attention. Since the tutor works with multiple students, personalised guidance may be limited compared to one-on-one sessions.
• Group dynamics can sometimes be tricky. Differences in learning speed, behaviour, or personalities can affect the overall experience and slow down progress for some.
• This format requires structure, tutors must plan carefully to manage timing, maintain engagement, and ensure every student gets the support they need.

How Many Students Work Best in Small Group Settings?

When setting up small group tutoring sessions, the number of students matters. Most tutors and experts recommend a group size of 3–6 students to balance engagement and personalised support. Once group sessions grow beyond this, it becomes harder to meet individual needs effectively.

According to the Education Endowment Foundation, once group size exceeds six or seven, the effectiveness of sessions tends to drop noticeably.

Small group settings work best when students are close in age or ability, and sessions are structured with clear learning objectives and regular feedback.

When One-to-One Tutoring Is the Best Choice

If your child is falling behind, lacks confidence, or needs structured help to reach top grades, one-on-one tutoring is almost always the best option. It provides a calm, safe environment where they can ask questions freely and build understanding without feeling judged or rushed.

It’s also ideal for high-achieving students who want to go beyond the school curriculum, prepare for entrance exams, or deepen their knowledge in a specific subject. While group lessons can support social learners, they often can’t offer the same level of personalisation, intensity, or flexibility that one-to-one tutoring provides.

Online vs In-Person One-on-One Tutoring

💙 Online One-on-One Tutoring

• One of the biggest advantages of online one-to-one tutoring is accessibility. Students can connect with expert tutors from anywhere, saving time on travel and allowing for more flexibility around school and family schedules.
• With tools like digital whiteboards, screen sharing, and interactive quizzes, online platforms offer engaging resources that help bring learning to life, especially for tech-savvy students.
• Online 1:1 sessions are also highly scalable. Whether your child needs help with a core subject, entrance exam prep, or boosting confidence, there are specialist tutors available across the country.

🔴 Challenges:

• Online tutoring does rely on stable internet and a quiet home environment. Some students may find it harder to stay focused on screen or miss the face-to-face connection that in-person sessions offer.

That said, when lessons are structured well and communication is clear, online one-on-one tutoring can be just as effective, and often more convenient, for busy families.

💙 In-Person One-on-One Tutoring

• The biggest strength of in-person 1:1 tutoring is the personal interaction. Being in the same room allows the tutor to read body language, spot confusion quickly, and adjust their teaching style in real time.
• It also reduces screen fatigue and tech-related issues. Many students feel more comfortable learning in a structured environment, especially when preparing for high-stakes exams.

🔴 Challenges:

• The main downside is logistics. In-person sessions require travel, coordination, and availability within a local area, which may limit choice, especially in rural locations.
• Tutoring costs may also be slightly higher due to travel time or venue expenses. But for students who thrive on real-world connection and need consistent academic focus, in-person one-to-one tutoring offers unmatched support.

Is One-on-One or Group Tutoring Better?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. If your child needs focused academic support, help catching up, or targeted exam preparation, one-on-one tutoring is likely the better fit. It offers personalised attention and flexibility that group sessions often can’t match.

That said, if your child enjoys learning with others or you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option for general support, group tutoring may still be a useful alternative.

Here’s a quick comparison:

Final Thoughts

One-on-one tutoring is the most effective way to deliver personalised, high-impact learning. Whether online or in-person, it allows tutors to tailor every lesson to the student’s needs, helping them build confidence, close knowledge gaps, and achieve academic success faster.

While group tutoring can offer social benefits and lower costs, it often lacks the individual focus required for consistent progress or exam readiness. For parents who want measurable results, flexible scheduling, and tailored support, 1:1 tutoring remains the gold standard.

Looking for the right tutor? Browse verified tutors on FindTutors and book your first lesson today!